True Stories, Told Live

Confabulation is Montreal's monthly all-true storytelling showcase. Every show brings together people from all walks of life — doctors, boxers, students, grandmas — to share honest, unscripted accounts without notes, props, or gimmicks. Hosted by actor and comedian Matt Goldberg, each night is a celebration of the personal and political histories that make this city unique.

Shows are held at MainLine Theatre (3997 St-Laurent, Montreal) at 8 PM. Admission is pay what you can.

Family

December: the most famliest month of the year. Every year around this time, Confabulation gets squishy for relatives and hosts the yearly fam jam — a good old-fashioned evening of stories about the people who shaped us.

A warm gouache painting of a family dinner table with soft amber light, deep browns, and cream tones, evoking intimacy and shared memory. A matte poster painting of overlapping silhouettes in muted ochre and charcoal, suggesting generations gathered together. A textured gouache scene of hands clasped around a warm mug, in earthy terracotta and slate blue, conveying comfort and connection.

Good Date / Bad Date

An evening of stories of remarkable first impressions and surprising results. Montreal's premier monthly all-true storytelling series returned to MainLine Theatre for a night devoted to the best and worst of romantic encounters.

A gouache poster of two chairs at a café table under warm amber light, with deep navy shadows, suggesting anticipation and vulnerability. A matte painting of a split scene — one side warm rose, the other cool grey — evoking the duality of good and bad dates. A textured gouache composition of a single rose against a dark charcoal background, petals slightly wilted, moody and romantic.

All in the Timing

Stories on and off cue, key, and beat — presented as part of the Bouge d'Ici Dance Festival. Confabulation explored the moments when timing is everything, and when it fails spectacularly.

A gouache poster of a stage spotlight cutting through deep indigo darkness, warm amber glow on the floor, suggesting performance and precision. A matte painting of a metronome in muted brass and slate tones against a cream background, evoking rhythm and timing. A textured gouache scene of dancers mid-motion in soft terracotta and charcoal, capturing the intersection of movement and story.

Truth or Dare

The leaves change and fall, the landlord plays with the heat — Confabulation looked truth square in the face and dared to tell the stories that matter most.

A gouache painting of autumn leaves in burnt orange and deep brown scattered across a dark surface, moody and contemplative. A matte poster of a single bare tree branch against a cream sky, rendered in muted umber and slate, evoking honesty and exposure. A textured gouache composition of overlapping faces in warm ochre and charcoal, suggesting confession and vulnerability.

Bad Medicine

Stories of cures, curses, and confusing the two. Confabulation explored the remedies that backfired, the diagnoses that missed the mark, and the healing that came from unexpected places.

A gouache poster of vintage medicine bottles in amber glass and slate shadows, arranged on a cream shelf, evoking old apothecary mood. A matte painting of a mortar and pestle in warm terracotta and deep charcoal, suggesting remedy and ritual. A textured gouache scene of a half-open door spilling warm light into a dark room, evoking uncertainty and the search for healing.

On the Road

Tales from the highway, the backroads, and the journeys that changed everything. Confabulation hit the road with stories of departure, arrival, and everything in between.

A gouache painting of an open road stretching into a hazy horizon, rendered in warm ochre and dusty blue, evoking freedom and distance. A matte poster of a rearview mirror reflecting a sunset sky in amber and rose, suggesting journeys and what's left behind. A textured gouache scene of tire tracks in snow, muted grey and cream, capturing the solitude of winter travel.

Down to the Wire

Stories of split-second decisions — the moments when everything hangs in the balance and a single choice changes the course of a life.

A gouache poster of a tightrope stretched across a deep indigo void, warm amber light catching the wire, evoking tension and risk. A matte painting of a clock face with hands at midnight, rendered in charcoal and cream, suggesting urgency and final moments.

The Shortest Story V – Nuit Blanche

2 theatres, 2 hosts, 32 stories, 1 Nuit Blanche. Confabulation's annual Nuit Blanche tradition returned with a marathon of two-minute tales — as many as could be fit into one unforgettable night.

Broken Telephone

Tales of miscommunication, misunderstanding, and mistaken identity — presented as part of the Bouge d'Ici dance festival. For January, that most confusing of months, Confabulation explored what happens when messages go awry.

Joe Conto: King of the Centerpiece

The best and worst stories I’ve heard at Confabulation

When I think about the best and worst stories I’ve heard at Confabulation, the distinction rarely comes down to whether a performance was dramatic, funny or beautifully written. Live storytelling has no safety net of a script, so the success of a story depends on what happens in the room as well as on the stage. A speaker can begin with a modest family memory and hold hundreds of strangers in complete silence. Another can reach for outrage, deliver a loud anecdote and leave everyone wishing the microphone had switched off.

Confabulation’s monthly gatherings at Montreal’s MainLine Theatre have always felt more like a shared evening than a conventional comedy show. Hosted by actor and comedian Matt Goldberg, the series gives people from varied backgrounds a place to tell true, unscripted stories about relationships, work, identity and change. Its pay-what-you-can model also shapes the atmosphere. Whatever people can contribute, they have bought a place in the audience, and that small exchange of money becomes part of the collective agreement: listen closely, because this person has chosen to risk something here.

The story that made the room go quiet

One of the best stories I remember involved a voicemail, a missed connection and a misunderstanding between two members of a family. The performer did not begin with a dramatic confession. She described the ordinary machinery of trying to contact a parent: the length of the message, the road noise in the background and the particular frustration of pressing the wrong button. What made the story powerful was its scale. The event that sounded trivial became the doorway to a much larger story about forgiveness and the limits of knowing another person’s intentions.

The strongest live stories usually work this way. They begin with something recognisable and allow the meaning to change gradually. A family disagreement is common; a funny voicemail played during the wrong moment is more specific. The audience can see the scene, hear the rhythm of the conversation and recognise a feeling without needing the performer to explain why it matters. Confabulation rewards this kind of precision because there is nowhere for a writer to hide. Every pause feels deliberate, even when it began as nerves.

What stayed with me was not a grand lesson but the feeling that the room had briefly become private. The performer trusted the audience with a small family fracture and did not turn it into a spectacle. Laughter came, then uncertainty, then silence. That progression is harder to engineer than a neat punchline. It depends on the teller’s control, the audience’s willingness to slow down and the acceptance that an unresolved ending can be emotionally complete.

When boldness stops being enough

The worst stories I’ve heard were not necessarily the angriest or most explicit. They were the ones in which a performer mistook exposure for connection. A painful event was described in vivid detail, but the audience was invited to laugh at someone whose pain had no relevance to the teller’s own growth. The moment felt like an ambush disguised as honesty. We were meant to feel shocked, not invited to understand why the story mattered.

Australian audiences know that difference well. In Sydney and Melbourne, open-mic nights can be generous, generous in the supportive sense, but they can also become competitive in the way of a pub trivia team chasing a bonus round. The performer wants the biggest reaction, the audience wants a memorable night and the fastest route to a laugh can become a substitute for a genuine narrative. I have seen enough improvised storytelling to recognise the trap: the room rewards energy first and substance later, if at all.

There is a useful distinction between raw material and raw storytelling. A performer may mention illness, discrimination, family violence or financial hardship, but the story still needs a reason for those details. They must reveal something about the relationship between the event and the person telling it. Without that work, disclosure can feel like theft, as though intimate material has been borrowed to make the teller interesting for the night.

The audience also carries a responsibility, though performers should never be made to manage it alone. Laughing is not betrayal, and discomfort is not proof that someone has told the story badly. The problem arises when a room starts treating a person’s vulnerability as a source of endless entertainment. That changes the agreement. Instead of being invited to listen, the audience becomes a crowd looking for the next exposed nerve.

Why the room matters as much as the tale

A live story does not remain the same once it leaves the performer’s imagination. In a small Montreal theatre, the audience can see someone searching for a word. In a large Australian auditorium, that moment may disappear. The physical setting matters, as does the price of admission, the host’s tone and the behaviour of the people already seated when the speaker walks out. MainLine Theatre’s modest scale makes eye contact almost unavoidable, which can feel both safer and more exposing.

That sense of proximity has become central to the series. An account of building community through vulnerability explains why Confabulation treats openness as a collective practice rather than a spectacle performed by bold individuals. The stories give strangers permission to recognise one another, while the audience has to do the emotional work of receiving them. The result is closer to a temporary neighbourhood than a collection of unrelated acts.

Australian live culture has plenty of close equivalents, even if the room often has another name. Melbourne’s laneway theatres, Sydney’s community halls and the improvised stages of small suburban pubs perform a similar function. People arrive for the comedy or music, then stay because somebody tells the truth with unusual care. Our everyday habits support this kind of encounter: an arvo coffee before work, a BYO bottle on a Friday night, or a walk home from the venue that gives a conversation time to continue beyond the applause.

The economics can be different, but the underlying bargain remains familiar. Venues pay rent, staff, sound engineers and performers, while audiences compare ticket prices with dinner and transport. Pay-what-you-can removes one barrier to participation, although many Australian audiences are also accustomed to contributing through donations, memberships and the simple habit of buying another round for somebody who has told a good story.

What makes an ordinary story travel

The most transferable stories are rarely the most spectacular. They are built from details that seem too small to matter: a supermarket receipt, the name of a bus route, a message left on an answering machine or the sound of a relative laughing in another room. Australian audiences recognise these anchors immediately. A Woolworths or Coles receipt folded inside an old handbag can carry more emotional weight than a carefully described financial crisis, because the receipt suggests a life not fully examined by its owner.

That specificity creates the first turn. The second arrives when the object or routine acquires a meaning the performer did not expect. Strong narrators understand that a story does not need an exotic setting to become universal. A delayed train in Montreal, a missed call in Adelaide or a family meal in Brisbane can contain the same uncertainty: the moment when you realise the person you thought you knew has been telling a different version of events.

The craft behind live narrative is discussed at gatherings such as the storytelling summit, where speakers can examine the relationship between performance, structure and audience. Yet the useful principles remain straightforward. Find the exact detail. Establish what the teller wants at the beginning. Delay the decisive revelation until the audience has made a connection. Most importantly, let the ending change the meaning of what came before it. Without that shift, the story may be interesting, but it remains only a sequence of things that happened.

The audience plays a part too. In theatre, people laugh at a pause, shift in their seat after a difficult disclosure or remain quiet when a speaker abandons a familiar comic rhythm. Those reactions affect the next beat. A live storyteller is not delivering a fixed message; she is listening, measuring the room and deciding whether to continue. The best performances feel spontaneous because the speaker remains fully alert to everything happening in front of them.

Trust, memory and the value of imperfection

Confabulation’s appeal lies partly in the knowledge that the stories are true, but “true” does not mean perfectly objective. Memory edits, family versions compete and emotional truth can change with time. A performer may know every date in a story and still misunderstand why it mattered. That uncertainty can be more revealing than a neat reconstruction, because it shows the narrator participating in their own life rather than delivering a polished case study.

Trust is especially important when stories concern other people. Australian event producers already navigate state and territory liquor-licensing rules, while the recording of a performance raises separate questions about consent, privacy and publication. Australia has no single privacy regime covering every situation; the Australian Privacy Principles apply to government organisations and many businesses, while state and territory laws fill other gaps. In practice, a clear agreement before recording is more reliable than assuming an audience understands where a personal story might later appear.

That legal patchwork does not remove the ethical issue. Permission should cover the identity of the person described, the details that could identify them and the contexts in which the recording may travel. A story may be factually true and still cause harm because it exposes a relationship, a health condition or a private disagreement. Thoughtful performers do not treat sensitivity as a flaw in the material. They treat it as part of the story’s responsibility.

The practical takeaway is simple: before telling someone else’s story, get permission, protect one detail that serves no narrative purpose and be ready to explain what changed for you. Those three checks protect trust and strengthen the story at the same time.

Zoe Daniels: What Comes After

From the Summer Love show, Zoe Daniels took the stage to share a story about what happens when the season fades and the real work begins.

Joel Fishbane: 40 Years of Love

From the Inherited Stories show, Joel Fishbane shared a tale spanning four decades of devotion — a story passed down and lived through.

Sage Tyrtle: Summer Love

From the Summer Love show, Sage Tyrtle brought a story of warm nights, fleeting romance, and the kind of love that only lasts a season — but stays with you forever.